When Algorithms Meet Aesthetics: The Promise and Pitfalls of AI in Dermatology

Welcome back, DERM Community!

Artificial intelligence has entered dermatology’s diagnostic arena and the headlines are bold.
 

“AI Outperforms Dermatologists in Detecting Melanoma.”
“Your Next Skin Check Could Be Done by an App.”

But beneath the buzz lies a critical question: 

Can machines really see what we see and more importantly, what we don’t?

In recent studies, convolutional neural networks (CNNs) trained on thousands of dermoscopic images have shown impressive accuracy, in some cases rivaling or even surpassing human dermatologists in classifying melanoma. 

These systems excel at pattern recognition and consistency, two areas where human fatigue and bias can interfere.

Yet, AI’s brilliance also highlights its blind spots. 

Algorithms are only as good as the data they’re fed and dermatologic datasets remain heavily biased toward lighter skin tones, specific image types, and controlled conditions. 

The result? 

Performance that can drop sharply when applied to real-world clinical diversity.

A dermatologist doesn’t just see a lesion; they contextualize it: factoring in history, patient behavior, lesion evolution, and subtle clinical cues outside the image frame. 

Machines, for now, remain confined to pixels.

That doesn’t mean AI isn’t valuable. 

When integrated thoughtfully, it can serve as a powerful assistant: triaging suspicious lesions, flagging high-risk cases for review, or helping underserved regions without dermatologists access expert-level screening. But AI should enhance, not replace, human judgment.

As clinicians, the challenge lies in defining collaboration (not competition) between human expertise and machine precision. 

The future of melanoma detection may not belong to either side alone, but to the partnership that blends empathy with algorithms.

We’ve Put Together a Free Guide Just for You!

This guide focuses on real-world utility: how AI assists with lesion analysis, what platforms clinicians actually use, what questions to ask before adopting any technology, and how to maintain a patient-centered approach as digital tools become more integrated into care.

Looking for a Job?

We got you.

Here are some job postings you may find interesting:

• Nurse Practitioner/Physician Assistant (Full time, Onsite) - Baymark - Sacramento, CA | Apply here

• Nurse Practitioner/Physician Assistant (Full time, Onsite) - Kroger Family Center - Cincinnati, OH | Apply here

• Physician Assistant (Full time, Onsite) - Valley Stream Pediatrics

•  - Valley Stream, NY | Apply here

• Physician Assistant (Full time, Onsite) - Morris Medical Asso

•  - Parsippany, NJ | Apply here

• Surgical Physician Assistant (Full time, Onsite) - Vassar Brothers Medical Center - Poughkeepsie, NY | Apply here

Want to Go Deeper?

Take one of our modules

Here are our three featured courses for today!

Book Recommendation of the Week

“Deep Medicine” by Eric Topol.

One of America's top doctors reveals how AI will empower physicians and revolutionize patient care.

Medicine has become inhuman, to disastrous effect. The doctor-patient relationship (the heart of medicine) is broken: doctors are too distracted and overwhelmed to truly connect with their patients, and medical errors and misdiagnoses abound.

In Deep Medicine, leading physician Eric Topol reveals how artificial intelligence can help.

Inspiration of the Week

👋🏻 See you next Thursday, DERM community!

Thanks for joining us on Beneath the Surface.

AI is changing dermatology’s landscape, but our greatest diagnostic tool remains the human mind: curious, critical, and compassionate.

Until next week, stay curious and keep looking beneath the surface.

— The Derm for Primary Care Team